Pricing is the part of reselling that quietly decides whether you make money. Price too high and your item sits for months. Price too low and you leave cash — sometimes a lot of it — on the table. Here's how to price secondhand items the way profitable resellers do.
Start with sold comps, not active listings
The single biggest mistake new resellers make is pricing against active listings. Active listings tell you what people are asking, not what buyers actually paid.
Instead, look at sold comps:
- On eBay, filter by "Sold items" and sort by most recent.
- Note the range — the lowest and highest a comparable item sold for.
- Throw out the obvious outliers (a damaged unit, a rare colorway).
What's left is your realistic market range.
Adjust for condition honestly
Condition can swing value 30–50%. Be ruthless with yourself:
- New / deadstock — top of the range.
- Used, excellent — mid range.
- Used, visible wear — bottom third.
- Flaws (stains, cracks, missing parts) — below range, and disclose them.
Buyers forgive honest flaws. They don't forgive surprises.
Factor in fees before you set a price
Your sale price is not your profit. A $100 sale on most marketplaces nets closer to $80–$85 after platform fees, payment processing, and shipping. Work backwards from the profit you want.
A simple mental model:
net = sale_price − platform_fee − shipping − cost_of_goods
If the net isn't worth your time to photograph, list, and ship, reprice or skip it.
Match the price to the platform
The same item is worth different amounts in different places. Hyped sneakers do best on StockX or GOAT. Trendy clothing moves on Depop. General goods clear fastest on eBay or Facebook Marketplace. Pricing without choosing the right venue is half a strategy.
Or: let AI do the comps in seconds
Manually pulling comps for every item is the slow part. AskPricing does it from a single photo — it identifies the item, pulls a low/suggested/high range from real resale data, scores condition, and tells you the best platform to sell on. What takes ten minutes of research becomes a three-second snapshot.
Pricing well is a habit. Build it with comps, honesty about condition, and fee math — then speed it up with the right tool.
← Back to all articles